A comparison of friedrich nietzsche and sigmund freud

This reading was criticized by Martin Heidegger in his s courses on Nietzsche—suggesting that raw physical or political power was not what Nietzsche had in mind.

Influence and reception of Friedrich Nietzsche

Mencken presented in his book on Nietzsche the "hard Nietzsche" little-known today; Nietzsche's actual, realistic philosophy of anti-egalitarian aristocratic revolution, Mencken's work standing in contrast positively to the "post-modernist" theoreticians of "linguistic schizo-analysis today", who try to turn Nietzsche into an all-American liberal without fangs.

First, the modernists rejected the traditional view that the world was a rational and orderly place. Freud, Civilization and Its Discontents, As a thinker, Nietzsche attacked the conventional opinions of his day because these opinions served as so many barriers to a fuller and richer human experience.

He concluded that disordered thinking was the result of fears experienced in childhood. Kaufmann offered, in more than one of his published works, lengthy and detailed criticisms of some of each man's ideas. Philosophers after Hegel have increasingly returned to face them, and they stand today unquestioned as the authentically great thinkers of their age.

Also inElisabeth gave to Hitler Nietzsche's favorite walking stick, and Hitler was photographed gazing into the eyes of a white marble bust of Nietzsche. Roux was a disciple of and influenced by Ernst Haeckel [7] who believed the struggle for existence occurred at the cellular level.

According to the French fascist Pierre Drieu la Rochelleit was the Nietzschean emphasis on the autotelic power of the Will that inspired the mystic voluntarism and political activism of his comrades. However, it is not always possible to determine whether or not they actually read his work.

The popular conservative writer, philosopher, poet, journalist and theological apologist of Catholicism G. Everything on our way is slippery and dangerous, and the ice that still supports us has become thin: This suggests that the will to power is stronger than the will to survive.

But what Nietzsche served to do was to further erode the rational foundations of western civilization.

Will to power

Both Jacques Derrida and Gilles Deleuze were careful to point out that the primary nature of will to power is unconscious. A Genealogy of Poststructuralism. Yet there were the differences between the two works. Kaufmann was a great admirer of both Nietzsche and Freud, but he said he was neither a Nietzschean nor a Freudian.

He condemned Christian morality. Wistrich has pointed out The "fascist" Nietzsche was above all considered to be a heroic opponent of necrotic Enlightenment "rationality" and a kind of spiritual vitalist, who had glorified war and violence in an age of herd-lemming shopkeepers, inspiring the anti-Marxist revolutions of the interwar period.

Russell is here depicting the "hard Nietzsche" very few today would recognize. He was buried in Highgate Cemetary in London, where around 10 mourners attended. To treat neurotic behavior, Freud argued that these childhood experiences must be brought to the surface so that the patient could confront himself with them.

A girlfriend of Mussolini, Margherita Sarfatti[14] who was Jewish, relates that Nietzsche virtually was the transforming factor in Mussolini's "conversion" from hard socialism to spiritualistic, ascetic fascism, [15]: From he was to find a living as a journalist.

Retrieved on June 8th, Against the tendencies of bourgeois society, Nietzsche stressed that man ought to recognize the dark and mysterious world of instinct -- the true life force.

Thanks to the help of influential admirers and sympatheisers, Freud was able to negotiate the escape of his immediate family and himself and so, at the age of 82, Freud moved to London.

He is fundamentally unsound. See Lecture 8 on modernism. The Impressionistscentered in Paris, broke with a tradition stretching back centuries. Nietzsche and anarchism[ edit ] Main article: Nietzsche, Freud and the Thrust Toward Modernism 2 If the development of civilization has such a far-reaching similarity to the development of the individual and if it employs the same methods, may we not be justified in reaching the diagnosis that, under the influence of cultural urges, some civilizations, or some epochs of civilization -- possibly the whole of mankind -- have become "neurotic"?

Christian morality must be obliterated because it is fit only for the weak and the slave. Numerous publications marked his time in London. This includes both such apparently[ need quotation to verify ] harmful acts as physical violencelying, and domination, on one hand, and such apparently non-harmful acts as gift-giving, loveand praise on the other—though its manifestations can be altered significantly, such as through art and aesthetic experience.

Freud treated his patients in two ways. In all his novels, Dostoevsky viewed man as innately depraved, irrational and rebellious. It blocked the free and spontaneous exercise of human instinct and will. In any case, Nietzschean ideas reached him through the filter of Alfred Rosenberg's Myth of the Twentieth Century, and, more simply, through what was coffeehouse Quatsch in Vienna and Munich.

Their approach was similar in that it was personal, emotive and immediate. Civilization, because it consistently thwarts our most basic human needs, has made man into something in-human.

Through this mechanism, the body grows stronger and better adapted.Freud and Nietzsche on Human Nature and Society After intensive analyzation of reading Civilization and It’s Discontents by Sigmund Freud and Beyond Good and Evil by Friedrich Nietzsche, I feel as if both Freud and Nietzsche offered virtually identical views.

Why Freud and Nietzsche works are often compared? up vote 3 down vote favorite. 2. He read Friedrich Nietzsche as a student, and analogies between his work and that of Nietzsche were pointed out almost as soon as he developed a following.[28] A somewhat superficial comparison can be made by listing similar terms and concepts.

Genius of the Modern World TV 1 Season Historian Bettany Hughes explores the intellectual landscapes that helped shape the work of Karl Marx, Friedrich Nietzsche and Sigmund Freud.

From the Paper: "Clearly, for Nietzsche, it is this desire to impose order upon the world that is the basic human drive, that which distinguishes people from animals, and is a basic need that all people share--which tells us why language exists, and science, and the law.

Friedrich Nietzsche in his “Thus Spoke Zarathustra” and “Beyond Good and Evil” praises the uniqueness of the superman over the crowd of people, the latter ‘blinded’ by the self-imposed frame of morality, religion, the notions of ‘good’ and ‘evil’, the ‘right’ and the ‘wrong’.

Nietzsche appe. Freud and Nietzsche and the Creation of Religion. For others, like Friedrich Nietzsche and Sigmund Freud, religion is an illusion that‟s associated with hatred a reality.

Timeline: Marx, Nietzsche and Freud

With this existential discovery by Nietzsche and Freud, with Nietzsche believing that morality, especially Christian morality, is a means to control a stimulus, and.

A comparison of friedrich nietzsche and sigmund freud
Rated 3/5 based on 13 review